How To Choose The Best Roofing Material For Your Home

December 15, 2023

Are you ready to take the first step towards enhancing your home's curb appeal and durability by investing in a new roof? You have come to the right place! Choosing the best roofing material is a crucial decision, as it not only affects the aesthetics of your home but also plays a significant role in its protection against the elements. The guide below will help you make an informed decision when selecting the right roofing material for your home. 

Aesthetics & Architectural Style

Your home's architectural style and your personal taste should influence your choice of roofing materials. Each material carries its unique aesthetic appeal, ranging from the classic look of asphalt shingles to the rustic charm of cedar shakes or the timeless elegance of slate. Harmonizing the roofing material with the overall style of your home enhances its visual appeal and can even increase its resale value. Consider the following materials to use for the various aesthetic styles below.


  • Asphalt shingles offer a classic look with a variety of color options.
  • Cedar shakes provide a timeless and rustic charm suitable for traditional homes.


  • Composite shingles offer sleek lines and a minimalist aesthetic.
  • Flat or low-slope roofing materials complement modern architecture with clean, horizontal lines.

Mediterranean/Spanish Revival:

  • Clay or concrete tiles embrace the warmth and authenticity of Mediterranean aesthetics.
  • Terracotta tiles provide a distinctive and earthy look, complementing Spanish-style homes.


  • Wood shingles enhance the cozy and charming appeal of cottage or craftsman homes.
  • Slate roofing adds an upscale touch while maintaining a connection to natural materials.

Colonial Revival:

  • Slate shingles mimic the historical authenticity of early American architecture.
  • Wood shakes blend seamlessly with the colonial revival aesthetic, offering a touch of tradition.

Rustic/Log Cabin:

  • Cedar shakes contribute to the natural and rustic feel of log cabin or rustic-style homes.
  • Metal roofing with a weathered finish enhances the aged and worn appearance for a more rustic appeal.

Victorian Style:

  • Patterned slate or clay tiles add intricate detailing that complements the ornate nature of Victorian architecture.
  • Ornamental metal roofing provides a decorative touch while maintaining durability.


  • Living roofs (green roofs) support vegetation growth, promoting eco-friendliness and energy efficiency.
  • Solar roofing tiles combine aesthetics with sustainability, contributing to green energy practices.

Climate & Weather Conditions

One of the foremost considerations in choosing roofing materials is your local climate and weather conditions. Different materials perform better in specific climates, so understanding the demands of your environment is essential. 

  • In areas with heavy rainfall or frequent storms, durable and water-resistant materials like asphalt shingles or metal roofing are excellent choices. Their ability to withstand moisture and resist damage from wind and hail make them ideal for such climates
  • In hot and sunny regions, where the scorching sun can take a toll on roofing materials, materials with reflective properties like metal or light-colored asphalt shingles are recommended. They help deflect sunlight, reducing heat absorption and minimizing the strain on your home's cooling system. 
  • In colder climates prone to snow and ice accumulation, metal roofing, as well as materials like slate and synthetic rubber, excel in preventing ice dams and ensuring efficient snow shedding. 

Each region's unique weather patterns demand tailored solutions, and understanding these considerations can guide homeowners towards selecting roofing materials that offer optimal performance and longevity in their specific climate.

Budget Considerations

Setting a realistic budget is paramount when embarking on a roofing project. Roofing materials vary widely in cost, and your budget will dictate the options available to you. Consider the upfront costs and the long-term value and maintenance requirements associated with each material. Do not forget that long-term value and maintenance requirements should also influence your decision when selecting the right roofing material for your home. It's important to note that the cost rankings below are generalizations, and the actual cost can vary based on factors such as geographic location, installation complexity, and specific product choices within each material category. 

  • Asphalt Shingles: Least expensive roofing material. Cost-effective and widely available.
  • Metal Roofing: Moderately priced, offering durability and longevity. Various metal options, including steel, aluminum, and copper, with different price points.
  • Wood Shingles or Shakes: Moderate cost, providing a natural and aesthetic appeal. Cedar shakes are a popular choice within this category.
  • Concrete Tiles: Higher in cost compared to asphalt and wood. Durable and available in various styles and colors.
  • Clay Tiles: Higher cost due to the material's durability and longevity. Distinctive appearance, often associated with Mediterranean or Spanish-style architecture.
  • Slate Roofing: Most expensive roofing material. Offers unparalleled longevity and a luxurious, high-end aesthetic.

Durability & Structural Compatibility

Longevity is a key factor when evaluating roofing materials. While some materials may have a higher upfront cost, they often offer greater durability, saving you money in the long run. Metal roofing, for example, is known for its longevity and resistance to harsh weather conditions, while asphalt shingles may require more frequent replacements. Consider the lifespan of the material in relation to your long-term housing plans.

Roofing materials also vary in weight, and the structural integrity of your home must be able to support the chosen material. Heavy materials like slate or tile may require additional structural reinforcement, adding to the overall project cost. Consult with a structural engineer to ensure that your home can safely accommodate the weight of your chosen roofing material.

Energy Efficiency

With a growing emphasis on sustainability, energy efficiency has become a crucial consideration in roofing choices. Solar roofing tiles represent a cutting-edge and environmentally conscious roofing solution, offering a plethora of benefits for homeowners looking to reduce their ecological footprint. The primary advantage lies in their capacity to harness solar energy and convert it into electricity, contributing to sustainable energy practices. These tiles seamlessly integrate into the overall aesthetic of a home, providing a visually appealing and streamlined alternative to traditional solar panels. By capturing sunlight and converting it into renewable energy, solar roofing tiles help homeowners significantly reduce their reliance on non-renewable energy sources, consequently lowering electricity bills and promoting energy independence. 

Furthermore, the installation of solar roofing tiles can enhance property value, as eco-friendly features increasingly become sought-after assets in the real estate market. With a focus on sustainability, reduced carbon emissions, and long-term cost savings, solar roofing tiles stand out as a forward-thinking and environmentally responsible choice for those looking to marry functionality with green living in their roofing decisions.

Local Building Codes & Consultations

When selecting a roofing material for your home, it is imperative to consider and adhere to local building codes and restrictions. Regulations are put in place to ensure the safety, structural integrity, and aesthetic harmony of buildings within a particular region. Local codes may dictate specific requirements regarding fire resistance, wind resistance, or even the types of materials allowed based on historical preservation considerations. Ignoring or neglecting these codes can lead to legal complications, project delays, and additional expenses. 

Before finalizing your decision on roofing materials, consult with local authorities or building departments to gain a comprehensive understanding of the rules governing your area. This proactive approach not only ensures compliance with the law but also contributes to a smooth and efficient roofing project that meets the necessary standards for your community. 

For even more information on the best roofing materials to use for your home in Utah, be sure to call Integrated Roofing Solutions today for a consultation!

Get A Quote